Fire Island
A Summer Retreat with Diverse Communities Atlantique is a charming community on the narrowest stretch of Fire Island, nestled between uninhabited federal land to the east and a public marina to the west. Home to a tight-knit group of over 50 homes, this spot thrives on simplicity and community. The unpaved, sandy Burma Road is a unique feature, adding a sense of adventure to hiking or biking. For a refreshing break, the Atlantique Marina’s small Shack offers food, drinks, and a chance to catch up on local gossip, making it a welcoming retreat for all.Cherry Grove, widely regarded as the oldest LGBTQ+ resort area on Fire Island, has been a vibrant haven since the 1940s. This iconic community of about 250 homes attracts artists, theater folks, and visitors looking for an unforgettable summer. The community boasts a bustling commercial district with shops, restaurants, and even a volunteer fire department. Its Community House and Theater, the oldest gay theater in the U.S., host various performances. A highlight of the summer is The Invasion, a fabulous July 4th event where drag queens from Cherry Grove cross to Fire Island Pines in a parade commemorating the 1976 protest against discrimination. This lively, historic event is one of the many reasons Cherry Grove is famous for its pride and flair.
Corneille Estates is a peaceful community located at the western edge of Ocean Beach, consisting of 70 homes. With no shops or commercial facilities, it offers a quiet, serene atmosphere perfect for a getaway. The area is home to Woodhull School, providing local education from Pre-K through 6th grade. Properties along Clipper Walk offer prime beachfront views and are accessible via scenic wooden boardwalks. Corneille Estates is ideal for those seeking a peaceful environment, with the added charm of nature and privacy.
Dunewood With only 99 homes, this residential area provides a low-key vibe, perfect for those looking to enjoy a relaxed summer. Dunewood features a private bay beach, the Dunewood Yacht Club, two tennis courts, and a public ocean beach with lifeguards. Children can enjoy swimming lessons, sailing, and tennis clinics. The Dunewood Property Owners Association ensures a peaceful environment by limiting group rentals. With no commercial distractions, this neighborhood is a true retreat.
Fire Island Pines, established in 1876 and incorporated in 1953, is an LGBTQ+ retreat that stretches 1.5 miles along Fire Island’s coastline. Known for its iconic Mid-century Modern homes and a thriving social scene, the Pines is home to about 640 homes and 100 co-op apartments. The community offers a wide range of amenities, including restaurants, bars, shops, and a hotel. Social causes are central to its identity, with regular fundraisers, Broadway-quality shows, and a dance festival. The Pines Party, an annual fundraiser and beach bash, and The Invasion are two of the most anticipated events of the summer, offering a fabulous display of pride and unity.
Kismet, located at the western tip of Fire Island, is the most year-round-friendly neighborhood on the island. With 260 homes and a charming commercial district, Kismet is a hub for both residents and visitors. The area boasts three popular restaurants, a pizzeria, a food market, and a marina. Public tennis courts and a playground make Kismet a relaxing home. Ferries from Bay Shore provide easy access to the area, making it a convenient destination for a laid-back day by the water or a fun night out.
Lonelyville is a secluded, serene community on the eastern edge of Dunewood. Originally a small 1950s real estate development, it now features 60 homes, offering peace and tranquility. With no commercial services nearby, Lonelyville is ideal for those seeking quiet relaxation. It’s easily accessible by ferry from Dunewood or Atlantique, and while the nearest commercial areas are Fair Harbor and Ocean Beach, Lonelyville provides the perfect blend of seclusion and convenience when you need it.
Ocean Bay Park (OBP) is a multi-generational community that blends convenience with charm. With just under 300 homes, OBP offers two restaurants, a grocery store, a liquor store, an ice cream parlor, pizzeria, and deli. Two hotels add a touch of hospitality, especially for weddings and short-term guests. While OBP lacks lifeguards, neighboring Seaview and Ocean Beach provide lifeguard services. The community is serviced by a strong fire department and receives EMS support from the Ocean Beach Fire Department. The Homeowner’s Association organizes popular events such as a Community Fair and provides rides to the ferry dock for seniors, making OBP a welcoming, tight-knit community.
Ocean Beach is the largest village on Fire Island, with about 600 homes. Recently renovated, the village offers a new ferry terminal, an expansive Community House, and Windswept building, home to the Ocean Beach Youth Group. The area features plenty of activities, including a ballfield, tennis and pickleball courts, basketball courts, and volleyball courts. For younger visitors, there’s a playground and swimming areas with lifeguards. Ocean Beach is a lively hub with restaurants, bars, and shops, making it a great spot for both relaxation and adventure.
Point O’Woods, a private community founded in 1894, offers a quiet, serene environment for those looking to escape the busyness of Fire Island. The community is owned by the Point O’Woods Association, which has been running the show since 1898. With no public services and its own private ferry, this community is perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat. It’s a place to relax, enjoy nature, and appreciate the quiet, low-key lifestyle that Point O’Woods offers.
Robbins Rest is a small, secluded hamlet between Ocean Beach and Atlantique, offering privacy and tranquility. With only 37 homes, Robbins Rest is accessed via the Burma Road, a sandy path that runs through undeveloped areas of the Fire Island National Seashore. This tight-knit community has no commercial services, making it a perfect retreat for those seeking a peaceful getaway. Its two main streets, Sextant Walk and Compass Walk, offer a quaint, laid-back vibe, ideal for those wanting to escape the hustle and bustle of busier parts of Fire Island.
Saltaire, founded in 1911, is one of only two incorporated villages on Fire Island, complete with its own Board of Trustees, Justice Court, and Public Safety departments. With over 400 homes, Saltaire is a residential community with limited commercial services, including a food market and liquor store. The community offers plenty of recreational activities, including a day camp, a playground, sports programs, and access to a marina and swimming areas with lifeguards. Saltaire’s Volunteer Fire Company provides fire and ambulance services, and the Saltaire Yacht Club offers sailing, tennis, and social events. The Saltaire Citizens’ Association organizes fun community events throughout the year, making it a vibrant and welcoming place.
Seaview is a peaceful, private residential community nestled between Ocean Bay Park and Ocean Beach. With 368 homes, Seaview offers a variety of amenities, including a licensed water company, private walks, a 55-slip boat basin, and lifeguarded beaches. Enjoy the playground, bay swimming area, tennis courts, and a ballfield. The community is known for its tranquil atmosphere and vibe, making it the perfect spot for relaxation and recreation.
Summer Club is a private, two-block enclave offering a secluded, bay-to-ocean lifestyle. Established in 1949, this condominium community of 45 homes provides exclusivity and privacy while remaining close to the activity of nearby Ocean Beach. Residents enjoy access to a private bay beach, boat moorings, a gym, a play area, and tennis courts. The community’s historic red-roofed building, originally a Coast Guard station, adds to the charm of this peaceful retreat.
Water Island is a quiet, diverse community with 50 homes, located between the Talisman/Barrett Beach area and Davis Park. Known for its Prohibition-era history, Water Island now offers a peaceful, no-frills retreat with no public services. The Water Island Association maintains a seasonal dock for weekend ferry service, and the community hosts an annual art show. With its tranquil ambiance and creative spirit, Water Island is perfect for those seeking a laid-back escape.
Fire Island’s diverse communities offer something for everyone—from lively hubs to peaceful retreats—and all with the island’s signature charm and natural beauty. Whether you’re seeking adventure, relaxation, or community, Fire Island has it all.